The H-1B court case ITServe Alliance v. USCIS consolidates several cases of information technology (IT) companies whose H-1B applications have been denied or approved with short validity periods. Judge Collyer’s ruling for this case could carry major implications for how U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) directs adjudicators to decide H-1B cases.
According to Forbes, Judge Collyer addressed three key issues in the lawsuit. “First, the government has yet to provide a good explanation for the disparate outcomes and adjudication processes for different types of employers—those with H-1B employees who perform work on customer sites and those who do not. The denial rates for initial H-1B petitions in [fiscal year] (FY) 2018 were 1% for large technology companies and 34% to 80% for companies that place H-1B [petition] holders at third-party sites.”
“Second, USCIS has to explain why it must require specific work assignments stretching out for three years for contractors even though the law permits H-1B professionals to be in ‘nonproductive’ time so long as they are paid.” “Third, Judge Collyer will decide whether discovery is warranted to find out what is behind the changes in USCIS adjudications of H-1B petitions.”